Publication Audit Package

Note

Generated by scripts/generate-traceability-report.py on 2026-06-28T10:31:47.

Status: draft-review-package.

This package assembles the method, evidence, traceability, AI-use disclosure, model-reliability disclosure, data-availability statement, validation gate, and public-readiness audit for scholarly review. It preserves draft boundaries rather than promoting the Lincoln pilot analysis as final.

Package Components

component status path purpose
Research design available RESEARCH_DESIGN.md Defines scope, method sequence, integrity rules, and evidence boundaries.
Corpus register available cases/lincoln/metadata/corpus-register.csv Documents included texts, provenance, rights status, and inclusion rationale.
Annotation codebook available MIPVU_ANNOTATION_GUIDE.md Defines MIPVU coding rules and review expectations.
Historical semantics notes available cases/lincoln/references/historical-semantics-notes.md Records period-meaning controls and semantic-risk notes.
MIPVU annotations available publication/audit/mipvu-annotations.csv Review-table export of lexical-unit metaphor decisions.
Reliability report available cases/lincoln/quality/reliability-report.md Shows the reliability sampling and adjudication workflow.
CMT mappings available publication/audit/cmt-mappings.csv Review-table export linking conceptual mappings to MIPVU evidence.
Corpus analysis available cases/lincoln/analysis/corpus-analysis.md Summarizes frequency, distribution, salience, and chronology.
Critical metaphor analysis available cases/lincoln/analysis/critical-metaphor-analysis.md Interprets persuasive and ideological functions.
Rhetorical/genre analysis available cases/lincoln/analysis/rhetorical-genre-analysis.md Controls claims by audience, occasion, genre, and agency structure.
Absence/agency analysis available cases/lincoln/analysis/absence-agency-analysis.md Records displacement, silence, and agency limits.
Historical enactment/alignment available cases/lincoln/analysis/historical-enactment-alignment.md Corroborates symbolic patterns against historical context.
Support ratings available cases/lincoln/analysis/support-ratings.csv Records document-level and case-level support scores.
Koenigsbergian support synthesis available cases/lincoln/analysis/koenigsbergian-support-synthesis.md Presents the draft evidentiary-support assessment.
Claim traceability available publication/claim-traceability.md Links support claims to evidence records and source metadata.
AI-use statement available publication/ai-use-statement.md Explains AI assistance and human scholarly responsibility.
Model-reliability disclosure available publication/model-reliability.md Separates accepted annotations, prior review, model diagnostics, human reliability, and reproducibility claims.
Model-reliability completion gate available docs/reliability/model-reliability-completion-checklist.md Defines the final artifact, authority, documentation, protected-path, and repository validation gate.
Human reliability methodology available human-reliability-methodology.qmd Defines blind human double-coding, adjudication, correction boundaries, and publication claim limits.
Human adjudication results available human-adjudication-results.qmd Publishes current human adjudication state, unresolved work, and correction-candidate consequences.
Human reliability status artifacts available cases/*/quality/human-reliability/status.json Machine-readable per-case human reliability execution status used to gate publication claims.
Human reliability completion gate available docs/reliability/human-reliability-completion-checklist.md Defines the final training, calibration, two-coder, metrics, adjudication, protected-path, publication, and repository validation gate.
Data availability available publication/data-availability.md Explains shareable data, rights status, and reuse cautions.
Validation gate available publication/validation-gate.md Documents the milestone-level rebuild, validation, and publication checks.
Public-site readiness available publication/public-site-readiness.md Shows draft/placeholder signals on public pages.

Traceability

  • Trace rows: 36
  • JSON: publication/audit/claim-traceability.json
  • CSV: publication/audit/claim-traceability.csv
  • Public table: publication/claim-traceability.md

Human Reliability Claim Gate

Claim status: no-complete-human-reliability-cohorts.

Human reliability claims are scoped to complete cohort rows only. Absent, designed, partial, invalid, awaiting-adjudication, and unresolved states may be disclosed but cannot support publication-ready human reliability claims.

Current package has no complete human reliability cohort rows; therefore no case/language/layer/cohort is publication-ready for a human reliability claim.

Complete Human Reliability Cohorts

No rows.

Case Status Rows

case_id state valid cohort_count valid_runs complete_cohort_count unresolved_adjudications warning_count error_count
am-rev absent True 0 0 0 0 1 0
fr-rev absent True 0 0 0 0 1 0
hitler absent True 0 0 0 0 1 0
lincoln designed True 1 0 0 0 1 0
napoleon absent True 0 0 0 0 1 0
wwi-britain absent True 0 0 0 0 1 0

Validation Gate

  • npm run status
  • npm run pipeline
  • npm run validate
  • quarto render

Public Site Readiness

Status: pass.

Report: publication/audit/public-site-readiness.json

Known Limitations

  • Trace rows are draft review aids, not final publication claims.
  • Publication-grade historical citations remain required where historical notes say so.
  • Scores are provisional and based on reviewed Lincoln pilot evidence.
  • Codex-assisted full-corpus MIPVU review is complete for the frozen pre-v1 corpus, but independent human review and reliability adjudication remain pending.
  • Historical alignment notes require publication-grade citations.
  • Accepted annotations and prior human-review artifacts remain distinct from multi-model diagnostic outputs.
  • Model agreement does not establish human inter-annotator reliability, scholarly reproducibility, or evidentiary correctness.
  • Model-reliability packets and responses inherit source-level rights and storage restrictions.
  • No case, source-language, task-layer, or cohort may be described as having completed human reliability unless it appears in the complete human reliability cohort table.
  • Incomplete, partial, invalid, awaiting-adjudication, or unresolved human reliability states keep related reliability claims draft.
  • Human agreement, model agreement, adjudication, and historical corroboration remain separate publication claims.