Case Comparison

Draft Comparison Matrix

case_id	case_type	status	support_rating	endpoint	claim_boundary
lincoln	civil-war-preservation-and-reunion	draft-scored	moderate support	Reunion, democratic survival, reconciliation, and renewal.	Lincoln is comparison-ready only as a provisional pilot case; full-corpus review and reliability adjudication remain pending.
hitler	genocidal-racial-state-violence	draft-scored	strong support	Racial state, Lebensraum, extermination of designated enemies, Thousand-Year Reich.	Hitler case is draft-scored; full-corpus German source review and reliability adjudication remain pending.
napoleon	imperial-war-mobilization	draft-scored	moderate support	Imperial consolidation, Napoleonic peace, historical glory; not extermination or republican founding.	Napoleon case is draft-scored from bulletin corpus; thin evidence base (19 instances) and genre constraints limit generalization.
am-rev	revolutionary-founding-violence	draft-scored	moderate support	Republican founding, constitutional self-governance, permanent severance from monarchical authority.	Am-Rev case is draft-scored; tech debt #42 means am-rev MIPVU pipeline may have overwritten reviewed annotations for Washington Orders documents.

Comparisons remain evidence-bound. Pending cases are not interpreted by analogy.